How sad I was recently to read the public post from former Nebraskan Senator and President of the University of Florida, Ben Sasse, who announced the following:
“Friends, This is a tough note to write, but since a bunch of you have started to suspect something, I’ll cut to the chase: Last week I was diagnosed with metastasized, stage-four pancreatic cancer, and am gonna die. Advanced pancreatic is nasty stuff; it’s a death sentence. But I already had a death sentence before last week too — we all do. I’m blessed with amazing siblings and half-a-dozen buddies that are genuinely brothers. As one of them put it, ‘Sure, you’re on the clock, but we’re all on the clock.’ Death is a wicked thief, and the bastard pursues us all. Still, I’ve got less time than I’d prefer…”
In 2018, Sasse wrote a book the Intramuralist believed to be spot on and brilliant. It’s entitled “Them: Why We Hate Each Other — and How to Heal.” In it he argues how America’s current state of extreme political polarization is not primarily a political crisis, but rather, a byproduct of a profound loneliness epidemic.
His point is that the erosion of “local tribes” — faith-based groups, neighborhood associations and service clubs — has left Americans feeling isolated. This isolation then activates physical pain responses in the brain, which often manifest as anger and resentment. No doubt in the 8 years since publication, we’ve all seen increased anger and resentment. One could look at the last few weeks alone.
Sasse maintains that to fill the void left by the community collapse, people have turned to partisan media. Sasse cleverly calls this “polititainment,” which is no doubt alive and well. This model and these partisans thrive on stoking outrage and “nutpicking” — plucking extreme examples from the opposing so-called side to justify painting them as a representative enemy. Here he suggests that hosts such as Sean Hannity and Rachel Maddow aren’t attempting to inform you; they want to make you mad. Such feeds the rage politics so in play today. It also highlights how journalism has eradicated the distinction between news and opinion.
Realizing its contemporary relevance, especially this week, allow us to share more nuggets of wisdom from “Them”…
“Right now partisan tribalism is statistically higher than at any point since the Civil War. Why? It’s certainly not because our political discussions are more important. It’s because the local, human relationships that anchored political talk have shriveled up. Alienated from each other, and uprooted from places we can call home, we’re reduced to shrieking.”
“Lacking meaningful attachments, people are finding a perverse bond in at least sharing a common enemy.”
“There is a deep and corrosive tribal impulse to act as if “The enemy of my enemy is my friend.” But sometimes the enemy of your enemy is just a jackass.”
“Many of our television hosts are modern-day carnival barkers. We get dopamine, adrenalin, and oxytocin all at once. It’s an adult video game. But instead of expertly separating us from our wallets, they’re separating us from things much more valuable. Our time, our sense of perspective, and our judgment. And they are separating us from each other.”
“Freedom depends on an informed citizenry, and an informed citizenry depends on serious journalism that takes facts seriously and grapples with those facts honestly. But good journalism is less and less likely when there are fewer and fewer readers with an appetite for something more than titillation. Producers and consumers work in tandem—for better or for worse. Right now, the pool of trust that once made that relationship constructive has all but dried up.”
“When one half of the nation demonizes the other half, tendrils of resentment reach out and strangle whatever charitable impulses remain in us.”
“We want an America with free speech, religion, press, assembly, and protest – even for those we disagree with.”
Thanks, Ben. You’ve got less time than we prefer, too.
Respectfully…
AR
